CHRISTMAS EVIL (1980)
SILENT NIGHT, BLOODY NIGHT (1974)

Directed by Lewis Jackson/Theodore Gershuny
Diamond DVD
Reviewed 12.22.04
Review by Joseph A. Ziemba


THE FILMS
Gather 'round the mistletoe! It’s Christmas time in the crypt o’ Bleeding Skull. And what’s this I see? An incredibly cheap (as in price, of course) holiday-horror double feature, certain to inspire the smell of pine and gingerbread for the entire season. Sometimes, I just can’t get over how much I enjoy budget DVD releases. Especially ones like this.

Before you start pointing fingers, I know perfectly well that both of these films are available via various companies on DVD. Christmas Evil even has its own special edition from Troma, complete with plentiful extras. But here’s the thing. I can’t go around buying EVERY disc I want, especially for films that I know little about. So when I’m presented with an exquisite seasonal double feature for much less than the price of a “normal” DVD, I can’t help it. The bill has been fit. More about those other releases later; we’ve got some snow to shovel.

Why is Christmas Evil, an unassuming, near perfect nail-biter, so effectively frightening? Because it could really happen, that’s why. We begin on Christmas eve, 1947. Little Harry and his brother have been visited by Santa (Dad). One hop up the chimney later and the boys are off to bed. Harry hears noises. Strolling down to the living room to investigate, Har gets the scar of his life, as he peers in on Santa and Mom...doing something that adults do. All grown up, Harry (Brandon Maggart) works a banal job at the tacky “Jolly Dream” Toy Factory. But that’s not all he does. Completely obsessed with Santa Claus, Harry sleeps in Kris Kringle’s duds, covers his apartment with holiday decorations, constantly hums X-mas carols, and spies on the neighborhood kids. See, he keeps actual leather-bound books of who’s been nice and who’s been naughty, pushing the creepy factor into the upper cosmos as a result. As Christmas time rolls around, Harry becomes increasingly frustrated with the hypocritical company he works for and the mistreatment he’s dealt with at the hands of his co-workers. After losing a few more marbles, Harry sews his own extravagant Saint Nick suit, takes to the streets on Christmas Eve, and dolls out rewards to the good people. And not so good people.

Christmas Evil is not what you’d expect. Sure, some horrific elements will peak your blood tooth, but this isn’t the typical trashy slasher junk. Instead, we’ve got an excellently acted snapshot (particularly Brandon Maggart’s performance) of a blemished man’s slow dive into surreality. Enthralling from the get-go, director Lewis Jackson (to date, his sole directing credit) offers up bushel-fulls of tight photography and emotionally draining interactions. Once Harry dons the suit, his awkward schizo tendencies come full force, as people aren’t quite sure how to react themselves. That leaves the viewer open for loads of surprises; from an out-of-nowhere gore sequence, to an uncomfortable speech that Harry bellows to some kids whilst in Santa mode. Despite his destructive behavior, you can’t help but feel sorry for the guy, a direct result of the well executed and solid build-up.

Then we have the reality aspect. Who’s to say that something like this couldn’t happen? Therein lies Christmas Evil’s strongest trait, as it never relies on the expected “invincible” killer humdrum. Harry’s existence is coated with a genuine sense of emptiness, from the dead-on depiction of a dead-end job to his claustrophobic freak-outs while driving. As the unexpectedly brilliant ending whisked away in my head, I quickly realized that Christmas Evil was something special; unique, accomplished, and very frightening. Wow.

If you’re expecting a letdown after that mind blower, I don’t blame you. Please, don’t be so hasty! There’s another stellar stocking stuffer that demands your attention. It’s called Silent Night, Bloody Night and it may very well be the very first Christmas-themed horror film ever produced. First time's a charm.

Here’s the scoop: the success of Silent Night hinges greatly on a couple of terrific twists and happenings that you won't see coming. I won’t ruin that for you. On Christmas Eve in 1952 (seems to be a popular night for evil mirth), Wilfred Butler, eccentric mansion-owner, blasts from his front door in a burst of flames. The coroner files it as an accident. Present day. An asylum patient escapes from the cuckoo bin. Butler’s estate was left to grandson Jeffrey, on one condition: that the interior of the house be kept exactly as Wilfred left it. That’s where Jeff’s hipster lawyer comes in. The time has come to sell the old homestead, so our Derek Flint-esque attorney makes an offer to the tiny town’s legislation (which includes John Carradine in a small, non-speaking role). They want to buy the place and destroy it; it’s haunted, of course! Next up is some brutal murder, a killer that’ll raise the shivers, and a masterful use of sparse, dusty locations.

Silent Night is a prime example of off-kilter, low budget horror done right. Maybe it was the dreary, always overcast skies; perhaps it was the sudden sepia-toned asylum flashback. Could it have been the appropriately skewed photography? Sure, some of the acting was a little stale, lead actress Mary Woronov in particular, but that comes with the territory. Bottom line: Silent Night thrilled me for two reasons. One, it sets out to be a dark creep-fest and thoroughly succeeds, and two, it was one of the first, paving the way for countless slashers during the next two decades. It's got that special something in spades -- cold scares and rough-edged charm. For now, this picture patiently bides its time until the rest of the world catches on. Now you know.

AUDIO AND VIDEO
Both films are readily available via various budget minded collections. But where else are you going to find such a cool-themed deuce? Aside from an older, impossible-to-find Catcom pairing, nowhere! Not having seen Christmas Evil, I’m happy to report that the full frame transfer here isn’t too shabby. It’s what you’d typically expect from budget quality (slightly rough print, compression artifacts, some audio pops), but remains entirely watchable. From what I was able to dig up, the Troma disc utilizes the exact same print. The mono sound was fine, but a slight buzzing was audible during moments of silence.

Silent Night, Bloody Night has been around the block a few times, seemingly popping up on at least one compilation from every major budget company. Although each release I’ve been able to compare (Platinum, Brentwood) offers up the same gritty full frame print, Diamond’s release trumps ‘em in terms of clarity. While the shimmery compression, thorough scratches, and occasional video blips are present throughout, the picture never breaks up into chunky artifacts ala the other releases. The mono sound was louder and less muffled as well. You know what? I’m not sure I’d ever like to see a pristine transfer for this film...the dirtiness only adds to the creeps.

EXTRAS
Chapter stops, the most basic of biographical notes, a listing of theatrical taglines, and a brief collections of screen shots (“Still Gallery”).

FINAL THOUGHTS
Bask in the cream of the holiday horror crop. In the race for greatest seasonal shocks, Christmas Evil and Silent Night, Bloody Night run neck in neck against Black Christmas for the golden ring. Both films are mandatory holiday viewing for people in our club. That means you.






Workshop tinkering


The touch


He decorated




We knew ye well


Death bed


On with the party